Ukrainian dancers
Ukrainian dancers, or traditionally Russian dancers, is a theme series of pastels by Edgar Degas depicting Ukrainian women performing ethnic dances. These paintings were created during the 1890s and early 1900s and were probably motivated by Ukrainian dancers performance in Paris of those times. Dancing women came from Russian Empire, so throughout the 20th century these paintings were attributed as "Russian dancers" in English and French sources, despite vast ethnographic and art historical evidence of Ukrainian origin of women.[1]
There were a number of voices calling for changing the misleading "Russian" name, criticizing it as "deliberate or just lazy misinterpretation" of Ukraine.[2] These calls intensified with the beginning of Russian invasion in Ukraine in February 2022. In response London's National Gallery renamed a painting from its collection as "Ukrainian dancers" in April 2022.[3][2]
Pastels
There are at least 18 pastels and sketches of Ukrainian dancers created by Degas, mostly in the second half of the 1890s.
Lisa Bixenstine classifies them as 6 finished pastels, 4 unfinished ones, and 8 sketches.[4]
Painting | Year | Technique | Canvas(cm) | Catalogue | Collection | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() | 1894 | pastel | 54 x 34 | MS 390 | private collection | [5] |
![]() | 1895 | pastel and charcoal | 48 x 67 | MS 392 | private collection | [6] |
![]() | 1895-1899 | tracing paper, pastel, charcoal | 62 x 67 | MS 383 | Nationalmuseum (Stockholm, Sweden) | [7] |
![]() | 1898 | pastel and charcoal | 73 x 59 | MS 389 | private collection | [8] |
![]() | 1898 | Pastel, charcoal and black chalk on paper mounted on cardboard | 67 x 57 | MS 394 | Museum of Fine Arts (Houston, USA) | [9] |
![]() | 1899 | tracing paper, pastel, charcoal | 62,2 x 62,9 | MS 384 | Museum of Fine Arts (Houston, USA) | [10] |
![]() | 1899 | paper, pastel | 62,9 x 64,7 | MS 385 | Metropolitan Museum of Art (New York, USA) | [11][12] |
![]() | 1899 | tracing paper, pastel, charcoal | 61,9 x 45,7 | MS 387 | Metropolitan Museum of Art (New York, USA) | [13][14] |
![]() | 1899 | pastel | 58,4 x 76,2 | MS 391 | private collection | [15] |
![]() | 1899 | Pastel and charcoal on 5 sheets of paper mounted on cardboard | 73 x 59,1 | MS 393, MS 1845 | National Gallery (London, Great Britain) | [16][17][18] |
![]() | 1899 | tracing paper, pastel, charcoal | 59,3 x 38 | MS 1533 | private collection | [19] |
![]() | 1900-1905 | paper, pastel, charcoal | 98,3 x 75,5 | MS 1204 | private collection | [20] |
![]() | paper, charcoal | Metropolitan Museum of Art (New York, USA) | ||||
![]() | с. 1899 | paper, pastel, charcoal | 63 x 60,8 | private collection | [21] | |
![]() | 1900-1905 | paper, pastel, charcoal | 54 x 71,1 | private collection | [22] | |
See also
References
- Bixenstine 1987, p. 105-110.
- Quinn, Ben (2022-04-03). "National Gallery renames Degas' Russian Dancers as Ukrainian Dancers". the Guardian. Retrieved 2022-05-03.
- Valentina Di Liscia. London's National Gallery Renames Degas's "Russian Dancers" as "Ukrainian Dancers". Hyperallergic, April 5, 2022
- Bixenstine 1987, p. 59.
- Danseuses russes. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Three Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Russian Dancer. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- "Russian Dancers". The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Retrieved 2022-01-24.
- Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- "Russian Dancer". The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Retrieved 2022-01-24.
- Russian dancer. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Danseuses russes. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- "Ukrainian Dancers". The National Gallery. Retrieved 2022-01-29.
- Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Danseuse russe. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Three Russian Dancers. The online critical catalogue of paintings and pastels by Edgar Degas by Michel Schulman.
- Impressionist & Modern Art Evening Sale/Lot 5. Sotbey's
- Live Auction 1429. Impressionist and Modern Art (Evening Sale). Cristie's
Sources
- Bixenstine, L. R. (1987). Edgar Degas' Russian dancers series (1897-99): their dating, pastel technique, and their context within his late period (1885-1908) (PhD thesis). The Ohio State University.
Literature
- Richard Kendall and Jill DeVonyar. Degas and the Ballet: Picturing Movement. Exhibition catalog, Royal Academy of Arts. London, 2011, pp. 19, 227, 229–31, 237
- David Bomford et al. in Art in the Making: Degas. Exhibition catalog, National Gallery. London, 2004