The Thing About Pam

• Renée Zellweger as Pam Hupp, a self-appointed businesswoman arrested for the murder of Betsy Faria
• Josh Duhamel as Joel Schwartz, the defense attorney for Russ Faria
• Judy Greer as Leah Askey, the Lincoln County prosecutor who tried Russ Faria twice for his wife's murder
• Gideon Adlon as Mariah Day, Betsy and Russ's 17-year-old daughter
• Sean Bridgers as Mark Hupp, Pam Hupp's husband
• Suanne Spoke as Janet, Betsy's mother and Mariah's grandmother
• Mac Brandt as Detective McCarrick, a detective assigned to Betsy's murder case
• Katy Mixon as Betsy Faria, Russ's wife, Mariah Day's mother, and the murder victim
• Glenn Fleshler as Russ Faria, Betsy's husband and Mariah's father

• Patricia French as Minnie, Pam's neighbor
• Ben Chase as Nate Swanson, a defense attorney working with Joel
• Drew Scheid as Travis Hupp, the son of Pam and Mark
• Celia Weston as Shirley Neumann, Pam's mother
• Heather Magee as Chris Mennemeyer, the judge in Russ's trial
• Alice Barrett-Mitchell as Cathy Singer, a journalist and producer at Dateline
• Dane Davenport as Mike Wood, a candidate for Lincoln County prosecutor and Joel's friend
• Jeff Ryan Baker as Louis Gumpenberger, a Missouri resident who is shot and killed by Pam

Dateline journalist Keith Morrison provides the show's narration.[1]

On January 10, 2020, NBC announced its plans to shut down the unscripted production unit Peacock Productions. Variety reported that the decision was sparked by the rise of streaming services and a necessity for "higher-quality productions". In a statement, NBC said the company was "shifting its documentary strategy to an entirely new model" that would be "consistent with industry trends".[8] Two weeks later, on January 23, NBC News Studios was launched. Liz Cole, executive producer of Dateline NBC and the then-president of Peacock Productions, announced she would also serve as president of the new company. The studio's intent is to produce documentaries, docu-series, select scripted programming, and content for emerging platforms. At the time of its announcement, NBC News Studios had already struck partnerships with Focus Features and Blumhouse Television, with the latter revealing they were in negotiations to develop and produce scripted programs based on stories told on Dateline. In a statement, Cole said "the documentary business is certainly more robust than it ever has been. More and more people are seeking out that content".[9]

On May 19, 2020, it was reported that NBC News Studios and Blumhouse Television were developing an untitled scripted television series based on coverage from Dateline about the involvement of Pam Hupp in the murder of Betsy Faria as well as the sentencing and release of her husband Russ Faria. Since 2014, Dateline had devoted several episodes to the story and created a podcast centered around the case in 2019 titled "The Thing About Pam". In a statement, Cole said that "having been at the forefront of the true-crime genre for so long, we know better than anyone that truth is often stranger than fiction, and with the twists and turns in this case, we saw a real opportunity to present it in a scripted format". In addition to the series announcement, it was revealed Cole would executive produce alongside Jason Blum, Marci Wiseman, and Jeremy Gold.[10]

Renée Zellweger (pictured in 2016) plays Pam Hupp in her network television debut.

The limited series was given a six-episode order and titled The Thing About Pam on February 4, 2021, with Renée Zellweger joining the cast to portray Hupp in her network television debut and attaching herself as an executive producer through her production company Big Picture Co. It was also reported NBCUniversal Chairman of Entertainment Content Susan Rovner would oversee the series and that Jessika Borsiczky would write and serve as showrunner. In a statement, Borsiczky said the murder case she was adapting could be interpreted as both a whodunit and a character study. Additional executive producers included Carmella Casinelli, Borsiczky, Noah Oppenheim, and Chris McCumber.[11] In May 2021, Jenny Klein signed a one-year first-look deal with Blumhouse Television and joined The Thing About Pam as a writer and executive producer.[12]

Marci Wiseman, following her resignation as Co-President of Blumhouse Television in October 2020, was later removed as an executive producer for the series.[13] In June 2021, Josh Duhamel was added to the cast with Mary Margaret Kunze joining as an executive producer.[14] By August 2021, The Thing About Pam was in the final stages of pre-production with casting still underway in New Orleans. On August 24, it was announced Borsiczky had exited the series as writer and showrunner due to creative differences but that she would remain an executive producer for the time being; Klein was appointed as the new showrunner.[15] On August 27, it was reported that pre-production would be suspended for some time due to Hurricane Ida with a filming start date set for early September.[16] On August 30, Judy Greer and Katy Mixon joined the cast.[17] On September 24, Gideon Adlon, Sean Bridgers, Glenn Fleshler, Suanne Spoke, and Mac Brandt were added to the cast.[18]

On September 28, 2021, Scott Winant was announced to be directing the first two episodes as well as executive producing. Filming was postponed until October 1, 2021.[19] At the second annual BlumFest in October, Zellweger spoke with Dateline correspondent Keith Morrison about portraying Hupp, "Truth is stranger than fiction. She's notorious, not famous. It won't be the same as coming to understanding a person's life experiences within context. [I am] going to be researching and trying to understand just based on the limited information that's available. I'm going to play the person that you sort of illuminated in your podcast and try to understand what makes a person like that tick".[20] Throughout October, Zellweger was photographed wearing face and body prosthetics to portray Hupp.[21][22] Filming took place in New Orleans and Hammond, Louisiana.[23]

Makeup artist Arjen Tuiten said it took eighty minutes to apply prosthetics on Zellweger. "It was Arjen who did all of the work. Arjen and Benadryl. I'm allergic to adhesives, and so there was a lot of comedy in the preparation," the actress remarked.[24] Hair department head Lawrence Davis and makeup department head Carla Brenholtz said they added light touches to prosecutor Leah Askey (played by Greer), based on a look anchored in Troy, Missouri.[25] In an interview with Vanity Fair, Zellweger revealed Morrison's role as the show's narrator and said her physical transformation was "pretty much head to toe".[1] When asked why they did not cast an actress with a closer resemblance of Hupp's physical appearance, McCumber replied, "When a two-time Oscar winner calls and says, 'I'm obsessed with this story and I want to play Pam and I want to produce, you say, 'Yes, yes, yes, yes.' And our job at that point is to provide Renee and the rest of the cast with all the tools they need to embody these characters."[26]

The score was composed by Giona Ostinelli and Sonya Belousova.[27] The theme implemented the use of an English horn, a prepared piano with coins between the strings, a harmonica, "ka-ching" sounds, a custom-made Italian instrument combining a waterphone and daxophone, and the sound of someone slurping. The slurping effect, which the duo came up with before filming began, was also used in the sound design.[28]

On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 43% of 23 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 6.0/10. The website's consensus reads, "Renée Zellweger is visibly having fun, but The Thing About Pam's glossy take on a true crime is neither as entertaining or insightful as it aims to be."[34] Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned a score of 58 out of 100 based on 16 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews".[35]

Zellweger's performance divided critics. Kimberly Potts of TheWrap said it appeared Zellweger was "thoroughly enjoying her time" as Hupp.[36] John Doyle of The Globe and Mail said the actress "brings an equal amount of vinegary exuberance to the work."[37] IndieWire's Ben Travers, on the other hand, called her performance "exaggerated".[38] From Vulture, Roxana Hadadi said "Zellweger is simultaneously broadly cartoonish and blandly nonspecific. She squints so much that her eyes lose whatever interiority they might have reflected; there is no real difference between her smile or her frown."[39] Variety's Daniel D'Addario criticized the "uncanny" prosthetics and the appearance of a Dateline producer as a character, writing, "It'd be a shame if Zellweger's first acting gig after her Oscar-boosted return to Hollywood were, ultimately, little more than NBC cross-promotion."[40]

The show's comedic tone was criticized. Brian Lowry at CNN called it a failed attempt to be "the next Fargo".[41] Liam Mathews at TVGuide said the "deliciously satisfying" tone was similar to that of the Coen brothers, but that its use to convey the story of a real murder would make "you feel [a] little queasy."[42] Ciara Wardlow, writing for RogerEbert.com, categorized it as "a watchable if often underwhelming true crime docudrama that wants to both be weird and play it safe, ending up in a strange middle ground between the two."[43] In a more positive review, The A.V. Club's Gwen Ihnat said "The Thing About Pam does an impressive job of translating an addictive tale to the small screen."[44]

The premiere episode increased its viewership by 205% after seven days, from 2.9 million viewers when it aired to 8.7 million viewers after a week with delayed viewing across linear and DVR, as well as Hulu, NBC.com, the NBC app, and Peacock.[45] By the end of its run on April 12, 2022, The Thing About Pam had become NBC's highest-rated freshman series of the 2021–2022 television season. It also had a positive impact on Dateline, especially on the viewership of the episodes about Hupp that inspired the series.[46]