June 1993 attack on Pakistani military in Somalia

The June 5th 1993 attack on Pakistanis was a major confrontation that occurred concurrently in different parts of in the Somali capital of Mogadishu, between Somali citizens & militias against the Pakistani peacekeeping contingent of UNOSOM II.[1][2] The event marked a seminal moment for the United Nations operation in Somalia. It was deadliest loss of U.N. peacekeepers since the Congo in 1961 and would consequently lead to UNOSOM II being primarily characterized by the hunt for General Mohammed Farah Aideed, which would directly lead to the deadly Bloody Monday raid and Battle of Mogadishu.[3][4][5]

A Pakistani armed convoy in Mogadishu, during the UNOSOM II peacekeeping operations.

Background and Rationale for inspection

An agreement had been previously signed between the warring Somali factions and UNOSOM to store heavy weaponry in "Authorized Weapons Storage Sites (AWSS)", which would be subject to U.N. inspections.[6] June 5th 1993 would be the first inspection of the AWSS.[3]

On the afternoon of Friday June 4th, the day before the battle, UNOSOM notified General Aideeds headquarters that they were planning to inspect six of his arms storage sites.[1] Notably only Aideeds faction was to be inspected.[6] The warning of the coming inspection was received by Aideeds lieutenant Abdi "Qeybdiib" Hassan Awale, as Aideed himself was not present to receive the warning with Friday being the Muslim day of Sabbath, and consequently he was off work.[6][4] Awale would protest that he was not authorized to accept such a notification, a claim which UNOSOM representatives rejected, and informed him that he was a recognized high official of the S.N.A/USC.[6][4] The visit was now considered as an official notification. He would warn:

"This is unacceptable, this means war."


Abdi "Qeybdiib" Awale [6][3]

This perceived slight greatly played into Aideeds growing fear that UNOSOM was attempting marginalize his authority in their effort to recreate the Somali state.[7][6] A 1994 U.N. Commission of Inquiry would conclude that the conflict had been set in motion by the decision to give Aideed the "ultimatum like" search notice.[8]

The Pakistani commander cautioned American General Thomas Montgomery that the inspections would be highly politically sensitive and dangerous.[3] Montgomery did not let tell the Pakistanis about Abdi "Qeybdiibs" warning and the Pakistanis claim if they had known about the objection they would have arrived better equipped.[3]

One of the "AWSS" was located at Radio Mogadishu, an immensely popular broadcasting station controlled by Aideed.[7] It had in recent weeks begun airing anti American and anti UNOSOM propaganda condemning interference in Somali politics after U.N. envoy Admiral Johnathan Howe had rejected the May peace conference he had set up.[7] On the airwaves Aideed would publicly accuse UNOSOM of "colonialization" and "imperialist designs".[3] Rumor quickly began spreading across the city that the UNOSOM had actually resolved to shut down Radio Mogadishu entirely, which further angered Aideed, rumors that were corroborated after the fact by the US special envoy to Somalia, Robert B. Oakley.[7][4] U.S. special forces technicians had also been sent to best determine how to disable the station.[3]

Aideed saw this action specifically as unfair as his main political rival, Ali Mahdi, also a radio station that was not being seized by UNOSOM, on account of his claim that it was "private".[7]

The attack

That particulars of what occurred, and who exactly initiated the battle is contested by UNOSOM and Somali accounts.[7]

On the morning of Saturday June 5th 1993 an element of the Pakistani force in Somalia had been tasked with the inspection of site "AWSS 5", which happened to be located at Aideed controlled Radio Mogadishu. The station was popular across the city, even among those who did not like Aideed or the Habr Gidr clan and concern that UNOSOM was coming to shut it down infuriated many citizens of Mogadishu.[6] As the Pakistanis entered the station a huge crowd of Somalis gathered in protest and began throwing stones yelling, "Go home UNOSOM! Go home!" and in response Pakistani peacekeepers opened fire into the air to ward off the growing angry mob.[6]

At 10 am when the inspections almost completed, fighting broke out in five different locations in the surrounding area.[1] At Radio Mogadishu, the Pakistanis quickly ran out of ammo and had to fend off grenade attacks using wooden planks as bats.[3]

The largest fight of the battle occurred about a mile from the stadium where the roughly 4,000 Pakistani troops in Mogadishu were stationed. Approximately 100 of them were driving back from the weapons inspections when they stopped to remove a roadblock and were ambushed Somalis militia. According to General Ikram that attackers were on both sides of the road, battling for two and a half hours with the Pakistanis, using heavy machine guns, rocket-propelled grenades and rocket launchers.[1]

Italian forces were called for help, but the dispatched helicopter would end up wounding three of the Pakistanis and armor support took hours to arrive.[3][4]

The fighting resulted in the death of 25 Pakistani soldiers and 16 to 35 Somalis according to hospital figures.[1][3] 59 Pakistanis and 3 Americans were wounded.[1] Aideed disputed the hospital figures, claiming 70 Somalis had been killed.[1]

The severity of the Pakistani death toll is attributed to the lack of armored cars, as many of those killed were shot as they tried to leave their cars to take cover in nearby houses and behind walls.[1]

According to the U.N.

At Radio Mogadishu, U.N. officials claimed that certain individuals had begun to incite the crowd and snipers opened fire. They further claim that two of the initial incidents of shooting were just a diversionary tactic to draw out peacekeeping troops.[1]

The Pakistanis would deny the Somali charge that they were attempting to seize Radio Mogadishu.[9]

U.N. accounts claim that militia mixed into the crowd had opened fire on the peacekeepers and initiated the battle at Radio Mogadishu.[3]

According to Mohammed Farah Aideed and Somalis

Somali accounts claim that the Pakistanis at Radio Mogadishu had opened fire on the crowd first, initiating the battle.[6][3]

"Then the soldiers lowered the muzzles of their guns and shot straight at people. I saw a young child of four and a girl about fifteen and a boy had been killed. I had not used my gun since the night at Villa Somalia (the night Somali dictator Siad Barre was driven from Mogadishu in 1991). I did not fight in the civil war, but now I ran to dig it up from where it was hidden."


Account of the incident at Radio Mogadishu according to young Somali named Abdiwele Ali in an interview with Mark Maren [6]

Somalis would claim that the inspection was actually a veiled attempt to shut down the station, and Resolution 837, passed the next day, fed into this narrative as it urged U.N. forces to, "...neutralize radio broadcasting systems that contribute to the violence and attacks directed against UNOSOM II".[9]

Aideed called for an independent investigation of the incident and claimed that the United Nations was not impartial and had a serious conflict of interest in judging an assault on its own forces.[6] A U.N. inquiry would conclude the next year that: "Without investigation, blame for the attacks of 5 June was laid on the "USC/SNA."[3][8]

Immediate reaction and ramifications

Resolution 837

The following day on June 6, 1993, the U.N. Security Council passed Resolution 837, calling for the arrest and prosecution of the persons responsible for the death and wounding of the peacekeepers. The Pakistanis, who had proposed the resolution, originally directly named Aideed in it, but was removed by the Americans and others who cited inadequate evidence.[7][10]

During private UNSC consultations, Russia proposed creating an international tribunal to try people who attacked U.N. personnel.[5][10] Russian Ambassador Yuli Vorontsov would argue the attackers should be punished through legal or military mean.[5] Jonathan Howe, the United Nations envoy to Somalia, would announce on UN radio that, "A full investigation will be made into the affair, and appropriate steps will be taken against those responsible." [1] It was soon after this that he put out the infamous $25,000 bounty on Aideeds head. The S.N.A would counter with a $1,000,000 bounty on Howe.[11]

In a further letter directly addressed to Aideed, that would become eerily prescient when the events of Bloody Monday would occur a month later, Howe would say:

"If the present course is pursued,"..."the results could cause further grief, especially for innocent and uninvolved Somali people. The casualties resulting from yesterday's attacks were excessive and inexplicable."


U.N. Envoy to Somalia Johnathan Howe[1]

Pakistani reaction

In Pakistan, Qazi Hussain Ahmed, head of the party Jamiat Islami would call for the total withdrawal of Pakistani troops following the attack, saying they were "only serving the interests of US imperialism in Somalia and its neighboring Muslim country, Sudan".[12]

8 days after the battle Pakistani peacekeepers fired into a crowd of civilians, killing children as young as ten and two years old, and at least 20 Somalis in total died. It would mark the first major instance of UNOSOM forces killing Somalis and would greatly feed into the growing anger of the citizens of Mogadishu against the peacekeepers.[13][14][15]

The UNOSOM II offensive against Aideed begins

Following the passing of Resolution 837 UNOSOM II forces would begin making offensive strikes all over Mogadishu with AC-130 gunships and helicopters.[16][17] On advice from the U.N., all aid work in the city came to a swift halt as the military campaign against Aideed began.[9]

UNOSOM would begin to greatly increase its firepower in Mogadishu and started making deliberate shows of force with Italian and American helicopters over the city.[18][19] The American Quick Reaction Force, after having been split up into several different hot spots in Somalia, was entirely recalled to Mogadishu.[1][20]

On the 17th of June, Aideeds compound would be directly targeted by AC-130 gunships in retaliation and Radio Mogadishu itself would also be destroyed.[20][21][22] Shortly before it was wiped out, the station would broadcast to the citizens of Mogadishu for the last time with, "We can see flagrant aggression and bullying against us."[23]

The U.N. would proceed to officially deal Aideed out of the Somali nation-building process.[24]

Johnathan Howe would begin to push Washington so hard for help in arresting Aideed that became known around the Clinton White House as "Jonathan Ahab."[24] Howe was convinced that apprehending Aideed, followed by trying him as a war criminal and removing him from Somalia - would help abate the raging civil war.[24]

Howe had also requested the deployment of Delta Force that June following the clash, but was rejected by President Clinton.[11] Howe had envisioned the small, secret Army unit dispatch small groups of well-trained soldiers who could mount a bloodless arrest of Aideed.[24] Delta began training for the operation early in the summer and commanders dispatched an assessment team to Somalia in June.[24] They reported that Aideed could easily be grabbed off the street.[24]

References

  1. Lorch, Donatella (1993-06-08). "U.N. Moves Troops to Somali City And Vows Punishment for Attack". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2022-03-14.
  2. "ON THE ATTACK | Maclean's | JUNE 28, 1993". Maclean's | The Complete Archive. Retrieved 2022-03-14.
  3. Peterson, Scott (2000). Me against my brother : at war in Somalia, Sudan, and Rwanda : a journalist reports from the battlefields of Africa. New York: Routledge. ISBN 0-415-92198-8. OCLC 43287853.
  4. Boulden, Jane (2001). Peace enforcement : the United Nations experience in Congo, Somalia, and Bosnia. Praeger. ISBN 0-275-96906-1. OCLC 925049446.
  5. "Dozens evacuated as fighting peaks; UN's bloodiest day since 1961". Edmonton Journal. 7 June 1993.
  6. Maren, Micheal (1997). The Road to Hell: The Ravaging Effects of Foreign Aid International Charity. United States: The Free Press. pp. 222–228. ISBN 0743227867.
  7. Oakley, Robert B. (1995). Somalia and Operation Restore Hope: Reflections on Peacemaking and Peacekeeping. United States: United States Institute of Peace Press. pp. 115–121. ISBN 1878379410.
  8. Report of the Commission of Inquiry Established Pursuant to Security Council Resolution 885 (1993) to Investigate Armed Attack on UNOSOM II Personnel Which Led to Casualties Among Them. 1994.
  9. "UN troops died 'trying to take Somali radio station': Security Council". The Independent. 1993-06-07. Retrieved 2022-04-16.
  10. "UN demands arrests in ambush: Somali attack leaves 22 Pakistani soldiers dead". The Globe and Mail. 7 June 1993.
  11. Bowden, Mark (2010). Black Hawk Down : A Story of Modern War. New York. ISBN 978-0-8021-4473-7. OCLC 456177378.
  12. "Pakistan grieves for its sepoys: Ahmed Rashid explains why Islamabad". The Independent. 1993-06-07. Retrieved 2022-04-16.
  13. "A little-known massacre explains Somalian hatred". Baltimore Sun. Retrieved 2022-03-14.
  14. "Pakistanis Fire on Somali Civilians; U.N. Renews Raids : Africa: At least 14 demonstrators are killed in shooting. Third aerial attack targets unauthorized vehicle storage sites controlled by warlord Aidid". Los Angeles Times. 1993-06-14. Retrieved 2022-03-14.
  15. Richburg, Keith (1993-06-14). "U.N. UNIT KILLS 14 SOMALI CIVILIANS". Washington Post. Retrieved 2022-03-14.
  16. "U.N. Forces Attack Somali Weapon Sites : Africa: U.S.-led assault targets clan leader Aidid's radio station, compounds and warehouses in retaliation for the ambush-killing of 23 Pakistani peacekeepers". Los Angeles Times. 1993-06-12. Retrieved 2022-03-16.
  17. "US bombs Somali warlord's arms cache after attacks: Artillery and". The Independent. 1993-06-06. Retrieved 2022-04-16.
  18. "U.S. Sends Gunships to Aid U.N. in Somalia : Africa: Wave of clan violence prompts move to beef up firepower. Military action against warlord is thought likely". Los Angeles Times. 1993-06-10. Retrieved 2022-03-16.
  19. "Mogadishu awaits UN punishment of Aideed: US and French troops roll". The Independent. 1993-06-09. Retrieved 2022-04-16.
  20. "TENSE STANDOFF IN SOMALIA". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved 2022-03-17.
  21. Richburg, Keith B. (1993-06-18). "U.N. TROOPS BATTLE SOMALIS". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2022-03-17.
  22. "SOMALI GUNMEN WOUND 2 U.S. SOLDIERS". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2022-03-17.
  23. "UN forces pound Somali warlord's lair". The Independent. 1993-06-12. Retrieved 2022-04-16.
  24. "A Wrong Turn In Somalia -- An Ill-Conceived Copter Raid Turned Many Somalis Against U.S. Forces | The Seattle Times". archive.seattletimes.com. Retrieved 2022-04-25.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.